Foreign Policy in Focus - A Think Tank Without Walls
Foreign Policy In Focus

FPIF Op-Ed

A Bold Step for U.S. Good Will in Iraq

Adil E. Shamoo | November 4, 2008

Email this page to a friend

Comment on this article

Foreign Policy In Focus

Originally published 11/4/08 in The Christian Science Monitor.

Here's a bold proposal for the next U.S. president: Issue an order to convert the controversial US Embassy in Baghdad into a university for the Iraqi people. This powerful message from our new leader would convey to the Iraqi people in particular a new direction for U.S. policy.

Reports suggest that U.S. combat troops will be on their way out by 2011. But the larger question of what gets left behind remains unanswered. The negotiations between Iraq and the United States on the long-term presence of U.S. combat troops haven't touched on the issue of the gigantic Green Zone and the U.S. Embassy inside it. What we leave behind will have a lasting effect on Iraq, the Iraqi people, and the rest of the Muslim world.

Currently, the sprawling embassy reminds Iraqis of their occupation by an alien nation. It reminds them of the power and wealth of the United States while they live in squalid conditions, in part, as a result of this occupation.

Even after U.S. troops leave Iraq, the embassy, in its current form, could remain a source of indignity to the Iraqi people. It could easily become the focus for all those who hate America for any reason and remain a target of violence.

Transforming it into a university, however, would be a striking symbol of American good will toward Iraq.

Why would the embassy make a fine university? Its outsized dimensions make it ideal for a university campus in a downtown urban area.

It's located in the heart of Baghdad on the banks of the Tigris River among Saddam Hussein's former palaces. The embassy complex sits on 104 acres with 27 buildings and facilities, costing more than $700 million. It can house about 5,000 staff. The Romanesque structure and fortress-like compound is the largest U.S. embassy in the world. And it is actually more like a small town than a diplomatic outpost. It's self-contained with water, electricity, power, a food court, a swimming pool, a gym, and other forms of recreation — amenities well suited to school the next generation of Iraqis.

The university could draw hundreds of faculty volunteers from the United States and Europe, including many of the thousands of expatriate Iraqi professors now residing in those countries, as well as Iraqi professors. (The US volunteers would teach for short stints and wouldn't be paid except for travel, lodging, and meals. The Iraqi professors would earn a regular salary.)

This transformation would signal a dramatic change. More important, this new university would annually train thousands of Iraqis in all disciplines essential to rebuilding the Iraqi infrastructure.

The university could be modeled after the outstanding American universities in Beirut and in Cairo, as well as the one under construction in Iraq's Kurdish region. It could be called the American University in Iraq.

These universities are primarily grant-funded and the recipients of donations from individuals. They're accredited in similar fashion to American universities. This accreditation would give the graduates access to further education anywhere in the world. This advantage would make the university very attractive to Iraqi students. The payment for the building cost could be negotiated between the U.S. and Iraq, and the Iraqi government could shoulder some of the operating costs.

The U.S. could then build a far smaller embassy that would be more appropriate for a country Iraq's size. And the Iraqi government, as in any other country, would take responsibility for protecting it.

Recently, Secretary of Defense Robert Gates, Admiral Michael Mullen (chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff), and General David Petraeus have stated that economic reconstruction for Iraq and Afghanistan is crucial. Transforming a symbol of military occupation into a symbol of good will is part of that reconstruction. It's the right thing to do — and it's consistent with American values.

Converting the U.S. Embassy in Baghdad into a university would mark a gigantic step toward reconciliation with Iraq. It would convey not only our long-range peaceful intentions towards Iraq, but also that our power resides in the talents of the American people and their values. Having our legacy in Iraq be symbolized by a university that helps Iraqis prepare for the future would be far better than letting it be defined by an American-occupied fortress.

Adil E. Shamoo, a senior analyst for Foreign Policy In Focus, is an Iraqi American and a professor at the University of Maryland School of Medicine. He writes on ethics and public policy.

 

Subscribe to
World Beat

FPIF's weekly ezine


Support FPIF


Christian Science Monitor Republished by Foreign Policy In Focus (FPIF), a project of the Institute for Policy Studies (IPS, online at www.ips-dc.org). Copyright © 2009, Institute for Policy Studies.

Published by Foreign Policy In Focus (FPIF), a project of the Institute for Policy Studies (IPS, online at www.ips-dc.org). Copyright © 2009, Institute for Policy Studies.

Recommended citation:
Adil E. Shamoo, "A Bold Step for U.S. Good Will in Iraq," (Washington, DC: Foreign Policy In Focus, November 4, 2008).

Web location:
http://fpif.org/fpiftxt/5644

Production Information:
Author(s): Adil E. Shamoo
Production: Jen Doak

Latest Comments & Conversation Area
Editor's Note: FPIF.org editors read and approve each comment. Comments are checked for content only; spelling and grammar errors are not corrected and comments that include vulgar language or libelous content are rejected.
 
Name Cyrous Moradi Date: Nov 04, 2008
The proposal to convert US embassy in Baghdad to University sounds interesting but I don't think it helps dramatically to build a secure and developed Iraq in the near future. The two models of American Universities of Beirut and Cairo as ideal model according to the article both are not successful as they assumed to be. These two universities have minor role in the development of the region and these two countries. Therefore there is no guaranty that a new one in Baghdad could be more successful than its previous models in Beirut and Cairo. Probably most of analysts presumed Iraq integrity is depended to Saddam and without him Iraq will face dis-integration. Now after 5 years of United States presence in this country, there is no immediate threat to its integrity and this is a big victory both for Iraqis and United States. I think it is better we wait to assess the success of American University in the North of Iraq. Probably it will be a good model of the future American universities in Baghdad and Basra.
Name Sally Powell-Ashby Date: Nov 06, 2008
I see the previous comment and realize that C Moradi has raised serious and thoughtful concerns. That being said, Tuesday, Novemember 4th was an historic day with the election of Barack Obama to the presidency of the United States. A day of unabashed hope and daring. I want to believe that the intention and vision of a university rising out of the U.S. Embassy can be acheived with great healing and growth for our global community. I am interested to know if there is a plan or beginning project to help realize this vision in Iraq as I would like to create a project in my community to help forward this transformation.
Name Brigitte Meier Date: Jan 06, 2009
I think Professor Shamoo's suggestion is excellent for many reasons: Saddam Hussein dominated Iraq with his palaces; the U.S. dominates Iraq with its military installations. Though both building types speak of supremacy over the people of Iraq, neither speaks of democracy. The new U.S. embassy is a fortress, not a world-open and world-accommodating building, least of all for the Iraqis, for whom the Green Zone is largely a forbidden city now. A university in that place would genuinely transform that place into one open to all Iraqis and the world. If the U.S. wants to go down in history as having brought lasting democracy to Iraq, then, yes, a university built in a place with so many palaces of so many despots, would be not just a symbol, but a reality of democracy taking hold to stay.
 
You may add a new comment here. It will not appear on this page until it has been approved by the moderator.
Your Name:
Comment:
 
Contact FPIF's webmaster with inquiries regarding the functionality of this website.
Copyright © 2009, Institute for Policy Studies.
 

Support FPIF

You Might Also Like:
 

Related Iraq Coverage

Iraq Policy Outlook: 2009
Mar 12, 2009

Feinstein: Bad Choice for Intelligence
Dec 23, 2008

A Bold Step for U.S. Good Will in Iraq
Nov 4, 2008